Starring Brad Pitt, Orlando Bloom, Brian Cox, Eric Bana, Diane Kruger
Also Starring Peter O’Toole, Sean Bean, Rose Byrne
Screenplay by David Benioff
Based on “The Iliad” by Homer
Directed by Wolfgang Petersen
Big budget historical war drama with a great cast: what could possibly go wrong? Quite a bit, actually. With a movie like this, there’s a lot that you know going in. It’s going to be big, it’s going to be beautiful, and there’s going to be lots of CGI battle sequences. That was all true. But what this film most desperately needed was a good script.
Despite the talented cast, most of the actors in this film were not able to breathe any life into the turgid, stilted dialogue. Even Brad Pitt, who is an actor that I have come to admire a great deal, was terrible in this film. But, in his defense, he had very little to work with. His character, Achilles, had very little personality, and many of his actions were completely unmotivated. It comes across very clearly that he wanted to be immortalized as a great warrior, but that’s about all. He has a strange relationship with a young priestess of Apollo named Briseis (Byrne). Apparently, he’s supposed to have some sort of genuine affection for this girl, but why? Where does that come from? No explanation is provided for why or how a notorious womanizer like Achilles suddenly falls in love with this one girl.
But, script-wise, the worst part of the film is clearly the opening, where Paris (Bloom) and Helen (Kruger) decide to run off together to Troy, despite the fact that this would start a bloody and devastating war. The love affair between these two violates one of the most important rules of film-making, which is to show, don’t tell. We are told hat these two people are in love, and have been in love for, oh, at least a few days prior to the opening of the film. But it doesn’t come across on an emotional level. It’s a plot point, and a bad one at that. If you want to take the gods out of the story, you have to provide motivation for events that, in the original epic poems, were motivated directly by the gods. Originally, Helen and Paris were matched up by the gods somehow. In the movie version, they decide to run off together despite the fact that they know this will start a war costing thousands of lives. It’s not very sympathetic toward them. Unfortunately, if you don’t buy the whole Paris and Helen thing, then you’re missing the entire premise of the film. It’s not a good way to start.
The film isn’t all bad, and the cast isn’t entirely bad either. Far from it. In smaller roles, Sean Bean and the great Peter O’Toole put in fine performances. Sean Bean’s Odysseus is one of the few genuinely likable characters in the film. O’Toole’s Priam is a tragic character, and a damn fool, but O’Toole’s performance engenders a great deal of sympathy. The best performance in the film comes from Eric Bana as Hector. Bana was also very good in last year’s obscenely under-rated
Hulk. If he can stay away from these big-budget pictures that underperform at the box office, he might be able to carve out a good career for himself.
Anyway, if you’re in the mood for a big, bold, beautiful, but painfully shallow film, then
Troy is for you. It’s basically your typical summer blockbuster: well-made, good cast, great visuals, and utter crap. I don’t know why I allow myself to get excited about thee duds year after year. I really do feel like an idiot for shelling out my hard-earned (and all too scarce) money to see this thing. I should have known better. The centerpiece of the advertising was the shot of the “thousand ships”, and lots of quick shots of various people fighting one another. That’s all this movie has. Skip it.